Our First Gym Had the Wrong Address. A Q&A Column Fixed It.

When I opened my first gym, we had a problem no amount of enthusiasm could fix: the location was not the best, and the town was a hard one to get people moving in. We opened a second club pretty quickly, mostly because we had to divide the marketing between two doors to make the numbers work at all. But two mediocre locations do not add up to one good one. We had to get creative.

Like everybody else in those days, we advertised in the local newspaper. Newspaper advertising was always pricey, and when you are a new club in a tough town, pricey is a problem. So we cut a deal with the paper. We would advertise with them on a regular basis, and in return, the paper would give us something money alone did not usually buy.

A column.

It was modeled on the old Dear Abby format. Readers would write in with their fitness questions, and the column would answer them. Ours was called Dear Paula. Paula was our manager, and she became the voice of it.

How do I lose 20 pounds in 30 days? How do I keep from gaining weight over the holidays? How do I get my figure back after having a baby? Real questions, from real people in our town, answered straight, in print, every week, with our club’s name attached to the help.

It worked really well. Better than the ads running next to it. It gave us credibility in that marketplace that a new club with a weak location had no business having, and credibility is the thing that gets a stranger to drive past two other gyms to come to yours.

Why a column beat the advertising

An ad says “trust us.” A column proves it. Any club can buy space and claim it knows fitness. Answering a new mother’s question about getting her figure back, in public, with your name on it, is a demonstration. Demonstrations beat claims every time, in every decade.

It answered the questions people were already asking. We did not have to guess what the market wanted to hear. They mailed it to us. Every letter was a prospect telling us exactly what was on her mind. All we had to do was answer honestly and well.

It put a person forward, not a logo. And notice: the person was not me. Paula was our manager. She was approachable, she knew her stuff, and readers connected with her. Owners think they have to be the face of everything. You do not. You need a face your market trusts, and sometimes the best face in your building is standing at your front desk.

It compounded. An ad runs once and it is gone. A column runs every week, and each week it is worth a little more than the week before, because the town starts to know the name. By the time a reader finally decided to join a gym, the decision had quietly been made months earlier, one answer at a time.

The lesson for your club

Strip away the newsprint and this is the same play I watch owners ignore today. The questions your market is asking have not changed: how do I lose the weight, how do I keep it off through the holidays, how do I get started again after the baby, after the injury, after the decade at a desk. What changed is where they ask them. They ask them online now, in searches, in groups, in comment sections, out loud to whoever will answer.

Somebody in your market is going to be the one who answers. It can be a stranger with a bigger advertising budget, or it can be you, in writing, every week, until your name and the word “help” mean the same thing in your town.

Our first gym had the wrong address in a hard town, and a question-and-answer column out-pulled the geography. Location is a handicap. Credibility is a cure. Shorten the learning curve and maximize bottom line profitability, and sometimes that starts with nothing more than answering the mail.

— Jim Thomas, Fitness Management & Consulting

Free Tools for Gym Owners

Free Gym Startup Bundle — the startup playbook, free right now.

Free calculators: Gym Churn · Gym Valuation · Member Lifetime Value · Cost of Empty Space

Want Jim to look at your numbers? Book a free strategy session.

Our Other Sites
close slider

Subscribe To Our YouTube Channel





Gyms For Sale

Call Jim: 214-629-7223Free Strategy Session